Skip to contentMert Sümbül Law Office

Area 11

Actions Arising from Enforcement Law

Actions to set aside an objection, declaratory actions for non-liability, third-party claims of ownership, and complaints arising from the enforcement process.

Matters handled

  • Actions to set aside an objection
  • Requests to remove an objection
  • Declaratory actions for non-liability and return of payment
  • Third-party ownership claim actions
  • Complaints against an act of the enforcement officer
  • Setting aside a foreclosure sale
Request an appointment

Which action, which court

Some disputes that arise during enforcement are heard by the enforcement court and some by the general courts. Choosing the right forum determines both the duration and the evidence that can be used:

  • Enforcement court: removal of an objection, complaints, setting aside a sale, third-party ownership claims, and objections to the debt or signature in negotiable-instrument proceedings
  • General courts: actions to set aside an objection, declaratory actions for non-liability, and actions for return of payment

The enforcement court generally decides quickly and on the documents; the general courts hear every kind of evidence, but proceedings take longer.

Step by step

  1. Reviewing the file: The enforcement file, the payment order, the objection, and the dates of service are reviewed; the periods for applying are calculated from those dates.
  2. Choosing the route: Depending on the nature of the document and the time remaining, it is decided whether to use a complaint, removal of an objection, a third-party ownership claim, or an action before the general courts.
  3. Application: The petition is filed, together with the supporting documents, at the enforcement court or the competent general court; the enforcement file number is stated in the petition.
  4. Interim measures and security: If the proceeding, or payment of the money to the creditor, needs to be stopped, this is requested together with the application; in most cases the court requires security.
  5. Examination: The enforcement court decides under the simplified procedure, mainly on the documents; an action before the general courts goes through the exchange of pleadings, the preliminary examination, and the taking of evidence.
  6. Judgment and appeal: An enforcement court decision can be appealed to the regional court of appeal within ten days of service of the decision (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Code, Art. 363); for general court judgments the period is two weeks (Code of Civil Procedure, Art. 345).
  7. Reflecting the outcome in the proceeding: The decision is submitted to the enforcement file; the proceeding then continues or stops, or the faulty act is corrected.

When a proceeding is suspended

There are two ways to get a proceeding suspended by the debtor's objection moving again. If you hold a document with an acknowledged signature, you can ask the enforcement court to have the objection removed (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Code, Art. 68); this route is fast but limited to a narrow list of documents.

If your document does not fall within that list, an action to set aside the objection is brought before the general courts (Art. 67). It takes longer, but proof by any means is possible.

Compensation for denial of debt

If the objection is found to have been unjustified, compensation for denial of debt may be awarded in the creditor's favour. This requires the receivable to be liquid (that is, definite and calculable) and the compensation to have been claimed in the initial petition.

Likewise, if the proceeding itself is found to have been unjustified, compensation for bad faith may be awarded in the debtor's favour.

Declaratory action for non-liability and action for return of payment

A debtor may bring a declaratory action for non-liability, claiming that no debt is owed (Art. 72). If brought before enforcement, suspension of the proceeding may be requested; if brought afterwards, only an interim measure preventing payment to the creditor may be sought. In both cases the court requires security.

If the money has already been paid, the action turns into one for the return of payment; in that case it must be shown that the payment was made under the pressure of enforcement.

Objecting to a garnishment notice

A creditor can attach the debtor's receivables held by third parties through a garnishment notice. If the bank, employer, or business counterparty receiving the notice does not state within seven days that it owes the debtor nothing, the debt is treated as its own (Art. 89).

A third party pursued because of a notice it did not object to in time can argue that it owes nothing through a declaratory action for non-liability; this route, however, is both long and costly.

Third-party claim of ownership

A claim that attached property belongs to a third party, not the debtor, is the subject of a third-party ownership claim action (Arts. 96-99). Who is in possession of the property determines which party bears the burden of proof.

Ownership claims by relatives living at the same address as the debtor are examined carefully because of the possibility that assets are being placed beyond reach.

Complaint

If an act of the enforcement office is contrary to law, recourse is had to a complaint before the enforcement court. The period is, as a rule, seven days from becoming aware; where public order is affected, a complaint may be made without a time limit (Art. 16).

Incorrect valuation, improper service, and claims of non-attachability are common subjects of this route.

Setting aside a sale

If there was an irregularity in the sale, such as collusion in the bidding or an improperly published sale notice, setting aside the sale may be requested (Art. 134). Only certain persons may make the request, and the irregularity must have affected the outcome of the sale.

An unjustified request may result in a monetary penalty against the person who made it; the request should therefore rest on a clear procedural error.

Documents to prepare

  • The enforcement file number, the payment order, the objection, and the dates of service
  • The contract, invoices, receipts, and correspondence showing whether the receivable or debt exists
  • For an ownership claim, invoices, lease agreements, and payment records showing the property belongs to you
  • The garnishment notice and proof of service
  • The sale notice, the valuation report, and the auction record

Deadlines

  • Action to set aside an objection: one year from notification of the objection (Art. 67)
  • Declaratory action for non-liability: before or during enforcement; action for return of payment within one year of payment (Art. 72)
  • Objecting to a garnishment notice: seven days from service (Art. 89)
  • Complaint: seven days from becoming aware (Art. 16)
  • Appeal against an enforcement court decision: ten days from service (Art. 363)

Common mistakes

  • Applying to the enforcement court when the document is not suitable for removal of an objection, and losing time
  • Failing to claim compensation for denial of debt in the initial petition
  • Bringing a declaratory action for non-liability without allowing for the security required for an interim measure
  • Disregarding a garnishment notice and not responding within seven days
  • Assuming every irregularity can be the subject of a complaint without a time limit, and missing the seven-day period
  • Bringing an ownership claim without preparing the documents that show ownership
  • Confusing the ten-day appeal period for enforcement court decisions with the two-week period for general court judgments

Related guides and articles

Other practice areas

Sports LawEnforcement and Bankruptcy LawConcordat and RestructuringCommercial LitigationBanking and Finance LawAll areas

Request an appointment

Share the documents and the stage of your actions arising from enforcement law matter; we will go through the available options together in a meeting.