Skip to contentMert Sümbül Law Office

Area 07

Collusion and Avoidance Actions

Avoidance and collusion actions brought against transfers made to place assets beyond a creditor's reach.

Matters handled

  • Actions to set aside fraudulent transfers
  • Title deed cancellation on grounds of collusion
  • Obtaining a certificate of insolvency
  • Gifts and transactions without consideration
  • Reviewing transfers to close relatives
  • Requests for precautionary attachment and interim measures
Request an appointment

Two different actions

There are two separate routes against transfers made by a debtor to place assets beyond a creditor's reach. An action to set aside a fraudulent transfer does not invalidate the transfer; it allows the creditor to enforce against that asset. In a title deed cancellation action based on a claim of collusion, it is argued that the transaction was invalid from the outset (Code of Obligations, Art. 19).

Which route to choose depends on the evidence available and the nature of the transfer. The two can also be raised together, in the alternative.

Step by step

  1. Enforcement and attempted collection: Enforcement proceedings are brought for the receivable, and assets registered in the debtor's name are searched for.
  2. Certificate of insolvency: If attachment does not cover the receivable, a temporary or final certificate of insolvency is obtained.
  3. Identifying the transfers: Past transfers of immovable property, vehicles, company shares, and funds are traced through title deed, traffic, and trade registry records.
  4. Interim measures: A precautionary attachment or interim measure is requested with, or before, the action to prevent the asset being transferred again.
  5. Action: The action is brought against both the debtor and the third party who acquired the asset.
  6. After judgment: If the action succeeds, the creditor may request attachment and sale of the transferred asset up to the amount of the receivable.

Who can bring the action

Any creditor holding a certificate of insolvency can bring an action to set aside a fraudulent transfer; if the debtor has gone bankrupt, this right passes to the bankruptcy administration (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Code, Art. 277). The action is brought against the debtor and the transferee and, where relevant, against later transferees who acquired the asset in bad faith.

The requirement of a certificate of insolvency

In an action to set aside a fraudulent transfer, the claimant must show that the receivable could not be collected from the debtor's assets. This is proven with a temporary or final certificate of insolvency (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Code, Arts. 105, 143).

The certificate can be obtained before the action is brought, or submitted during the proceedings. Its complete absence leads to the dismissal of the action.

Which transactions can be set aside

The law lists three groups of transactions:

  • Gifts and transfers treated as gifts, where there is a clear disproportion between the values exchanged (Art. 278)
  • Transactions carried out while insolvent, such as providing security for an existing debt (Art. 279)
  • Transactions found to have been made with the intent to place assets beyond a creditor's reach (Art. 280)

For transfers to a spouse, descendants, and close relatives, a strong presumption applies that the intent to place assets beyond reach was known.

Deadline

An action to set aside a fraudulent transfer must be brought within five years of the date of the transaction (Art. 284). This is a time bar (a peremptory period); the court takes it into account of its own motion, and if it is missed the action is dismissed without an examination of the merits.

For a title deed cancellation action based on a claim of collusion, no time limit generally applies.

Proof

In these actions, proof rests not only on documents but on the ordinary course of events: whether the transfer price was actually paid, the buyer's ability to pay, how close in time the transfer was to the enforcement proceedings, and the relationship between the parties are all assessed together.

Requesting an interim measure before the action is brought, to prevent the property from being transferred again, is often decisive in such files.

What the judgment achieves

A judgment setting aside a transfer does not return the asset to the debtor or change the title deed record. It gives the creditor the right to request attachment and sale of the asset while it remains registered in the third party's name. If the third party has disposed of the asset, liability arises for the value that took its place.

The judgment has effect only for the creditor who brought the action and for that receivable. Other creditors of the same debtor cannot benefit from it directly.

Documents to prepare

  • The basis of the receivable and the enforcement file details
  • A temporary or final certificate of insolvency
  • Title deed, vehicle, or trade registry records of the transfer
  • Documents showing the asset's value at the time of transfer, or comparable sales
  • Information showing the relationship between the debtor and the transferee (family, partnership, employment)
  • Bank records, if it is claimed that the price was paid

Common mistakes

  • Bringing the action without a certificate of insolvency and failing to obtain one during the proceedings
  • Missing the five-year time bar because enforcement dragged on
  • Not joining the third-party transferee as a defendant
  • Searching only title deed records for the debtor's transfers; vehicles, company shares, and bank transfers should also be examined
  • Delaying the request for an interim measure; the asset may be transferred again while the action is pending
  • Using an action to set aside and a collusion claim interchangeably; their conditions and effects differ

Related guides and articles

Other practice areas

Defective Consent ActionsTitle Deed Cancellation and Registration ActionsReal Estate LawActions Arising from Enforcement LawSports LawAll areas

Request an appointment

Share the documents and the stage of your collusion and avoidance actions matter; we will go through the available options together in a meeting.