Skip to contentMert Sümbül Law Office

Area 06

Contract and Obligations Law

Drafting contracts, disputes over performance and termination, and claims for receivables and compensation.

Matters handled

  • Drafting and reviewing contracts
  • Disputes over default and performance
  • Withdrawal from and termination of contracts
  • Claims for penalty clauses
  • Receivable and compensation actions
  • Unjust enrichment
Request an appointment

When a contract is drawn up

A large share of disputes arise because a contract was never put in writing, or because a ready-made template was used that does not match the parties' actual way of working.

A good contract is not a long one, but one that clearly shows the parties' obligations, the time of performance, what happens in the event of breach, and where a dispute will be resolved.

Formal requirements

As a rule, contracts are not subject to any particular form; an oral agreement is also binding (Code of Obligations, Art. 12). However, contracts for which the law specifically requires a form are not valid unless that form is observed. The sale of immovable property and a preliminary sale agreement require an official form; a suretyship requires written form with handwritten elements.

Even where no form is required, a written text is the safest means of proof if a dispute arises.

What a contract should contain

  • The parties' full names or trade names, addresses, and authorised representatives
  • A clear description of the performance: what will be delivered, which service will be provided, and to what standard
  • The price, the payment schedule, and the interest applicable on late payment
  • The place and time of performance; the delivery and acceptance procedure
  • Notice, grace-period, and termination conditions in case of breach
  • Any penalty clause and its relationship to compensation
  • Addresses for notices, and the competent court or arbitration clause

Default

When a debtor fails to perform, the creditor's rights depend on whether default has occurred. In most cases a formal notice is required; however, if a due date has been set, default arises without the need for a notice (Art. 117).

After default, the creditor may seek performance in kind along with compensation for delay, or, where the conditions are met, may withdraw from the contract and claim negative damages instead (Art. 125). These choices lead to different outcomes and are difficult to reverse.

When a dispute arises, step by step

  1. Read the contract and the correspondence together: Identify which provision of the contract the breach affects.
  2. Send a notice: Send a written, provable notice to put the debtor in default and set a deadline.
  3. Choose the remedy: Performance and compensation for delay, or withdrawal from the contract; assess the consequences before deciding.
  4. Check the mediation requirement: If the parties are merchants, or the dispute is of a type listed in the law, mediation may be mandatory before litigation.
  5. Action or enforcement: If the receivable is definite, enforcement proceedings are considered; otherwise, an action for the receivable or for compensation.

Penalty clauses

A penalty clause included in a contract is a powerful tool because it can be claimed without proving loss. However, an excessive penalty clause may be reduced by the judge (Art. 182); between merchants, no such reduction is possible (Turkish Commercial Code, Art. 22).

Whether compensation may also be claimed alongside the penalty clause depends on the wording of the contract; this point should be settled when the text is drafted.

The risk of wrongful termination

Terminating a contract is often the first step that comes to mind. However, if it later turns out that the termination was not based on just cause, the terminating party faces a claim for compensation.

Before terminating, it should be checked whether the breach genuinely makes the contract unsustainable and whether the required notice and grace-period steps have been completed.

If circumstances change: adaptation

If, after the contract is concluded, an extraordinary change that the parties could not foresee makes performance excessively onerous for the debtor, the debtor may ask the judge to adapt the contract to the new circumstances or, if that is not possible, to withdraw from it (Code of Obligations, Art. 138).

Adaptation is an exceptional route; the change must have been unforeseeable, and the debtor must have performed under reservation or not yet performed.

Unjust enrichment

A payment made on the basis of an invalid contract, or a sum given for a purpose that did not materialise, can be reclaimed under the rules on unjust enrichment (Art. 77). The claim becomes time-barred two years after the claimant learns of the right to reclaim, and in any event ten years after the enrichment (Art. 82).

Limitation periods

The limitation period varies according to the type of receivable: the general period is ten years, and a five-year period applies to periodic obligations such as rent and interest (Arts. 146, 147). The period can be interrupted before it expires by bringing an action or initiating enforcement proceedings.

A limitation defence is not considered by the court on its own initiative unless it is raised (Art. 161); for this reason, the defendant, too, must assess this point in time.

Documents to prepare

  • The contract, its annexes, and any later amendments
  • Correspondence, e-mails, and messages between the parties
  • Delivery reports, invoices, and payment receipts relating to performance
  • Formal notices sent and received
  • Documents showing how the loss is calculated
  • Signature circulars or powers of attorney showing the parties' authority to act

Common mistakes

  • Working on an oral agreement without keeping the correspondence
  • Using a template prepared for a different transaction without adapting it
  • Terminating the contract without sending a notice
  • Setting a penalty that is disproportionate to the main obligation; for a non-merchant party the judge may reduce it, and the contract loses its deterrent effect
  • Not assessing the consequences before exercising a remedy
  • Waiting without checking the limitation period, or whether a partial payment or acknowledgment of debt has interrupted it

Other practice areas

Collusion and Avoidance ActionsDefective Consent ActionsTitle Deed Cancellation and Registration ActionsReal Estate LawActions Arising from Enforcement LawAll areas

Request an appointment

Share the documents and the stage of your contract and obligations law matter; we will go through the available options together in a meeting.